Social Care Inspector
Gemma McDonnell
Active in published reports from May 2019 to Aug 2026.
Inspections
228
As lead
171
75% of visits
Last 12 months
25
Remits
2
Social care 200 · Other 28
Grades given vs. national, last 5 years
Social care115 graded by Gemma
Gemma
National
| Outstanding | 11% | 12% | 0 |
| Good | 62% | 68% | -6 |
| Requires improvement to be good | 17% | 15% | +3 |
| Inadequate | 10% | 6% | +4 |
Inspections by year
Writing style
From 134 reports, each compared with reports of the same type that got the same grade. Language only: it says nothing about the judgements themselves.
Gemma McDonnell's reports read more critical than others with the same grade (warmer than 10% of inspectors).
more criticaltypicalwarmer
- Tone vs peers
- −11
- Length
- −13%
- Next steps
- 3.3
- per report
- Hedged
- 4%
- of sentences
Topics that come up most in their reports
Staff development 76%Leadership & governance 75%Progress & outcomes 64%Teaching & assessment 54%Care & placements 50%Wellbeing & mental health 44%Records & policies 44%Safeguarding 43%
Area grades (report cards and judgements)
Helped and protected134
Leadership and management134
All inspections (228)
- Monitoring visit
- Outstanding
- Kyloe House12 Aug 2026 ·Children's Home, Secure Unit· Northumberland· critical tone· Gemma McDonnell, Dave CarriganAssurance
- Inadequate
- Good
- Report
- Clare Lodge4 Jun 2026 ·Children's home· Peterborough· mixed tone· Leanne Lyon, Daniel Carrick, Dave Carrigan +2Report
- Good
- Clayfields House Secure Unit30 Apr 2026 ·Children's home· Broxtowe· mixed tone· Gemma McDonnell, Carolyn Brownsea, Daniel Carrick +5Report
- Good
- Monitoring visit
- Aycliffe Secure Services19 Mar 2026 ·Children's home· County Durham· mixed tone· Leanne Lyon, Gemma McDonnell, Jo BirtwhistleReport
- Clare Lodge11 Feb 2026 ·Children's home· Peterborough· critical tone· Gemma McDonnell, Jo Birtwhistle, Leanne Lyon +1Report
- Monitoring visit
- Adel Beck Secure Children's Home22 Jan 2026 ·Children's Home, Secure Unit· Leeds· positive tone· Gemma McDonnell, Debbie Foster, Leanne LyonReport
- Adel Beck Secure Children's Home20 Jan 2026 ·Children's Home, Secure Unit· Leeds· positive tone· Gemma McDonnell, Dave Carrigan, Leanne LyonAssurance
- Atkinson Unit15 Jan 2026 ·Children's Home, Secure Unit· Devon· positive tone· Shaun Common, Gemma McDonnell, Joanna Walters +1Report
- Assurance
- Aycliffe Secure Services11 Dec 2025 ·Children's home· County Durham· critical tone· Gemma McDonnell, Jo Birtwhistle, Leanne LyonReport
- Good
- Outstanding
- RI to be good
- Barton Moss Secure Care Centre13 Nov 2025 ·Children's Home, Secure Unit· Salford· very positive tone· Gemma McDonnell, Gary Turney, Jo Birtwhistle +1Report
- Good
- Assurance
Show all 228 inspections
- Assurance
- Report
- Good
- Outstanding
- Good
- Good
- Monitoring visit
- Clayfields House Secure Unit7 Aug 2025 ·Children's home· Broxtowe· mostly positive tone· Gemma McDonnell, Cath Sikakana, Suzanne Wainright +1Report
- Assurance
- Assurance
- Good
- Good
- Good
- The William Henry Smith School and Sixth Form17 Jun 2025 ·Residential Special School· Calderdale· very positive tone· Gemma McDonnell, Steve GuireyOutstanding
- Assurance
- Barton Moss Secure Care Centre28 May 2025 ·Children's Home, Secure Unit· Salford· mostly positive tone· Shaun Common, Gemma McDonnellMonitoring visit
- Vinney Green Secure Unit22 May 2025 ·Children's home· South Gloucestershire· mostly positive tone· Thirza Smith, Gemma McDonnell, Jo Birtwhistle +1Report
- Kyloe House13 May 2025 ·Children's Home, Secure Unit· Northumberland· positive tone· Tash Williams, Gemma McDonnellAssurance
- RI to be good
- Good
- Aldine House Secure Centre17 Apr 2025 ·Children's home· Sheffield· positive tone· Tash Williams, Debbie Foster, Gemma McDonnell +1Report
- Good
- Children's Home, Residential special school run by The National Autistic Society in Barnsley14 Mar 2025 ·Children's Home, Residential special school· Barnsley· critical tone· Gemma McDonnell, Jo BirtwhistleAssurance
- Assurance
- Good
- Oasis Restore Trust13 Feb 2025 ·Children's Home, Secure Unit· Medway· mixed tone· Thirza Smith, Carolyne Brownsea, Gemma McDonnell +1Report
- Outstanding
- Aycliffe Secure Services30 Jan 2025 ·Children's home· County Durham· positive tone· Gary Turney, Cath Sikakana, Gemma McDonnell +2Report
- Assurance
- Assurance
- Marydale Lodge16 Jan 2025 ·Children's Home, Secure Unit· St Helens· positive tone· Thirza Smith, Gemma McDonnell, Tash WilliamsReport
- Barton Moss Secure Care Centre12 Dec 2024 ·Children's Home, Secure Unit· Salford· positive tone· Gemma McDonnell, Carolyne Brownsea, Gary Turney +1Report
- Assurance
- Good
- The William Henry Smith School and Sixth Form20 Nov 2024 ·Residential Special School· Calderdale· very positive tone· Gemma McDonnell, Jo BirtwhistleOutstanding
- Good
- RI to be good
- Lincolnshire Secure Unit7 Nov 2024 ·Children's Home, Secure Unit· Lincolnshire· very positive tone· Cath Sikakana, Anita Pyrkotsch-Jones, Gemma McDonnell +1Report
- Outstanding
- Outstanding
- Kyloe House26 Sept 2024 ·Children's Home, Secure Unit· Northumberland· positive tone· Debbie Foster, Cath Sikakana, Gemma McDonnell +4Report
- Monitoring visit
- Clayfields House Secure Unit12 Sept 2024 ·Children's home· Broxtowe· positive tone· Debbie Foster, Carolyn Brownsea, Gary Turney +2Report
- Good
- RI to be good
- Assurance
- Good
- Aldine House Secure Centre11 Jul 2024 ·Children's home· Sheffield· mostly positive tone· Debbie Foster, Cath Sikakana, Gemma McDonnell +1Report
- Report
- Good
- Good
- Monitoring visit
- Good
- Swanwick Lodge2 May 2024 ·Children's Home, Secure Unit· Hampshire· very positive tone· Gary Turney, Gemma McDonnell, Martin WardReport
- Clare Lodge25 Apr 2024 ·Children's home· Peterborough· mixed tone· Dawn Parton, Cathey Moriarty, Gemma McDonnell +1Report
- RI to be good
- Assurance
- Good
- RI to be good
- Good
- Assurance
- Monitoring visit
- Oakfield22 Feb 2024 ·Residential Special School· Kingston upon Hull· positive tone· Gemma McDonnell, Steve GuireyGood
- Children's Home, Residential special school run by The National Autistic Society in Barnsley13 Feb 2024 ·Children's Home, Residential special school· Barnsley· very positive tone· Gemma McDonnell, Janine Shortman-ThomasGood
- St John's Catholic Specialist School, Boston Spa8 Feb 2024 ·Residential Special School· Leeds· very positive tone· Aaron Mcloughlin, Gemma McDonnellGood
- Clayfields House Secure Unit25 Jan 2024 ·Children's home· Broxtowe· positive tone· Debbie Foster, Gary Turney, Gemma McDonnell +1Report
- Assurance
- Outstanding
- Assurance
- RI to be good
- Good
- Outstanding
- Inadequate
- Abbey School for Exceptional Children13 Oct 2023 ·Residential Special School· Cheshire West and Chester· positive tone· Gemma McDonnell, Judith BirchallGood
- Good
- Inadequate
- Good
- Good
- Monitoring visit
- RI to be good
- RI to be good
- RI to be good
- RI to be good
- RI to be good
- Inadequate
- Inadequate
- St Anne’s School and Sixth Form College28 Jun 2023 ·Social care· East Riding of Yorkshire· positive tone· Aaron Mcloughlin, Gemma McDonnellGood
- Good
- Monitoring visit
- Outstanding
- Inadequate
- Elemore Hall School12 May 2023 ·Social care· County Durham· positive tone· Jamie Richardson, Gemma McDonnell, Rachel RuthGood
- Monitoring visit
- Assurance
- Good
- Good
- Monitoring visit
- Inadequate
- Assurance
- Assurance
- Good
- Children's Home, Residential special school run by The National Autistic Society in Barnsley23 Feb 2023 ·Children's Home, Residential special school· Barnsley· mixed tone· Jennifer Fenlon, Gemma McDonnellGood
- Good
- Good
- Children's Home run by Vcare - 24 Limited in East Riding of Yorkshire1 Feb 2023 ·Children's Home· East Riding of Yorkshire· mostly positive tone· Gemma McDonnell, Miriam DolmanGood
- Children's Home, Residential special school run by The National Autistic Society in Barnsley30 Jan 2023 ·Children's Home, Residential special school· Barnsley· mostly positive tone· Jennifer Fenlon, Gemma McDonnellMonitoring visit
- Good
- Good
- RI to be good
- Good
- Children's Home, Residential special school run by The National Autistic Society in Barnsley4 Jan 2023 ·Children's Home, Residential special school· Barnsley· mostly positive tone· Jennifer Fenlon, Gemma McDonnellMonitoring visit
- RI to be good
- Good
- The William Henry Smith School and Sixth Form16 Nov 2022 ·Residential Special School· Calderdale· very positive tone· Jane Titley, Gemma McDonnellOutstanding
- Children's Home, Residential special school run by The National Autistic Society in Barnsley9 Nov 2022 ·Children's Home, Residential special school· Barnsley· very critical tone· Jennifer Fenlon, Gemma McDonnellInadequate
- Good
- Good
- Good
- Monitoring visit
- RI to be good
- Cedar House School29 Sept 2022 ·Residential Special School· North Yorkshire· very positive tone· Jane Titley, Gemma McDonnellOutstanding
- Good
- Inadequate
- Good
- RI to be good
- Good
- Good
- Inadequate
- Monitoring visit
- Good
- RI to be good
- Monitoring visit
- Children's Home run by Vcare - 24 Limited in East Riding of Yorkshire8 Jun 2022 ·Children's Home· East Riding of Yorkshire· mostly positive tone· Gemma McDonnell, Aasia HussainGood
- RI to be good
- Inadequate
- RI to be good
- Inspection
- Inspection
- Good
- Good
- Good
- Good
- Good
- Inspection
- Good
- Good
- Good
- Good
- Good
- Good
- Good
- Good
- Good
- Inspection
- Good
- RI to be good
- Good
- Good
- Outstanding
- Good
- Report
- RI to be good
- Good
- Good
- Monitoring visit
- Good
- Good
- Good
- Good
- Good
- Monitoring visit
- RI to be good
- RI to be good
- Outstanding
- Children's Home run by Tees-Valley Care Limited in Redcar and Cleveland25 May 2021 ·Children's Home· Redcar and Cleveland· critical tone· Gemma McDonnell, Jamie RichardsonRI to be good
- Outstanding
- Good
- RI to be good
- Inadequate
- Good
- Monitoring visit
- Monitoring visit
- Monitoring visit
- Monitoring visit
- Report
- Monitoring visit
- Monitoring visit
- Monitoring visit
- Children's Home, Residential special school run by Ruskin Mill Trust Limited in Sheffield2 Feb 2021 ·Children's Home, Residential special school· Sheffield· mostly positive tone· Noel Cooper, Gemma McDonnellReport
- Monitoring visit
- Children's Home run by North East Lincolnshire Council in North East Lincolnshire25 Jan 2021 ·Children's Home· North East Lincolnshire· critical tone· Jennifer Fenlon, Gemma McDonnellMonitoring visit
- Monitoring visit
- Monitoring visit
- Assurance
- Assurance
- Assurance
- Assurance
- Assurance
- Assurance
- Assurance
- Assurance
- Assurance
- Inspection
Where they've inspected
Often inspects with
Member ratings
Been inspected by Gemma McDonnell? Join free to read reviews and rate your experience.
Rate this inspectorExperiences of Gemma McDonnell
Members compare notes on inspectors and inspections here. Join free to read and post.
Join the discussion